Leadership Gone Wild?
Our Belligerent Presidential Candidates
“He who wishes to fight must first count the cost…
When you engage in actual fighting, if victory is long in coming…
men’s weapons will grow dull and their ardor will be dampened.” Sun Tzu
Something keeps nagging at me about our “leaders.” And when I hear candidates, particularly GOP, talk tough-fluff, their prattle goes right to my gut. Some talk of carpet bombing which is illegal; and apparently they don’t know that; or perhaps they don’t care. Others talk about “bombing them until the sand glows and taking their oil.” Really? And what will the countries be doing while being bombed, oil being confiscated, smiling?
I often think of what I saw in Viet Nam, and how I saw us. We were Americans: tall, many of us more than 6 feet, well fed, bodacious, audacious, heavily equipped, dressed in jungle boots, fatigues, state-of-the-art stuff: F4 fighter jets, A6 Intruders, B52s bombers, Huey Cobra attack helicopters, personnel carriers, tanks, battle ships. I was lucky enough to watch the USS New Jersey firing off the coast of Da Nang; and when it fired, seemingly the entire globe shook—an awesome machine, etc., etc. We were bad asses; so we thought. I often heard, “We’re going to kick some VC ass, Whoaa!”
Well, the Viet Cong didn’t have such modern weaponry, equipment; they weren’t six feet, grain-fed. Many range from 4 feet to perhaps 5 feet plus, dressed in black cotton pants and shirts, resembling pajamas, and often without combat boots or jungle boots, but rather tongs or what we consider sandals, and in some cases, no shoes, a backpack, and either an AK 47 or a “Chicom” machine gun (Chinese Communist).
Here’s the zinger! We, during the more than 10 years fighting, dropped, some eight (8) Billion Ton of Bombs, more than in World War II (Europe and Asia). For 10 years, night and day, we dropped 8 billion tons of bombs covering an area only about the size of California or Japan. Imagine sitting in San Francisco or Sacramento and having to escape incoming by scurrying to the bunkers often several times during the night. We lost! They defeated us. Recall, we hurried to rooftop of the US Embassy to catch the last helicopter out of country. It was a war where the giant superpower was unable to defeat a small, developing, tenacious country. And yes, we lost some 58,000 service members; a terrible loss of life that rippled into so many families and communities back home. We also ended the lives of some 3, 000,000 (that’s million) Vietnamese; of those killed, 80% were civilians, probably planning for fall harvest, gathering at the water point each day, who had nothing to do with why the war was happening all around them. And we did not, as Sun Tzu said, “count the cost.”
I likened it to the little mosquito keeping the giant awake at night. And the giant just can’t get his hands on that mosquito. Mosquito or not, we were defeated! And we don’t seem to have the courage to discuss it, or analyze it, and learn from it. And I also believe we are at the precipice of war again, with a mindset of belligerence and dominance. Again, the awakening giant trying to swat a swarm of mosquitos: tenacious, brazen, and deadly. And if those wanting war were to win, we will repeat the same again: losing thousands of lives on both sides or on all sides. I believe we are very slow learners; we fear new knowledge.
I fear most of our candidates and many of our country leaders do not have the heart and knowledge to shrink their ego, access their wisdom, and lead; they are not equipped to command this nation in a radically and rapidly changing world.
What say you?
Great point from an experienced soldier who has truly reflected on personal experience. Thank you Dr. David Whitfield.
Humility = Reflection on Experience X Truth X Enlightenment X Wisdom X Knowledge X Learning X Understanding
Buchi, S.J. (Your former student at Gonzaga University)
Wow! OMG! First, it’s a pleasure hearing from you; it’s been a long, long time; and thank you very, very much, Father Muoneme! I remember you distinctly and you went by Buchi. Second, I must apologize for not responding to your post. Not only did I have an illness, I have also been a bit overloaded.
Third, our “Humility” formula is very expressive and enlightening. I wonder why some of or most of our leaders didn’t get that “Memo.” I also wonder where we are headed as a nation. We don’t practice or engage in Reflection on our Experience because we’re afraid to admit mistakes (our best teachers as you know). When it comes to Truth, we make lying a commodity; it makes money by selling fast and furious, sadly—Truth doesn’t sell. The elements of your equation are too, very practical: Learning seemingly has become a burden; yet without it, we die. Without Learning we forfeit Knowledge and Understanding.
Finally, I believe had we practiced your expression in general and Enlightenment in particular, we would have avoided death, destruction, and embarrassment from having lied our way into Viet Nam and Iraq.
I thank you so very much, Buchi! And I look forward to hearing from you in the future and reading your comments.
Great point from an experienced soldier who has truly reflected on personal experience. Thank you Dr. David Whitfield.
Humility = Reflection on Experience X Truth X Enlightenment X Wisdom X Knowledge X Learning X Understanding
Buchi, S.J. (Your former student at Gonzaga University)
Hi Dave. This is great first-hand insight. I like the deepness of this presentation. I also like Einstein’s equation. As an ordinary man looking at it, would I be wrong to say that empty barrels make the most noise? And yes, at the time of the war I was living in a part of the world considered even today as very remote. We had a round, bulky black and white television screen. We watched the news every evening. We saw bamboo fields, people with v-shaped hats hiding under thickets. We also saw helicopters on fire and coming down from mid-skies with large broken blades. Those were days when Saigon and Hanoi, representing words like north and south, were common expressions in the news. We saw people on stretchers. We could not speak a lot of English then, but though we knew which side we were on, we were sorry for all the human beings who were dying and being carried hurriedly across fields. If we could, we would stop the senseless loss but… Today we can, we shall not support any idea of war and loss of young lives. Yes, I believe aspirant presidential candidates ought to think again about wars and how they may not be the best way to solving problems. I think this American expression “constructive engagement” should be borrowed at all times bipartisan-ly. Wars are not fashionable, they should not be platformed on anyone’s presidential campaign, they lead to loss of limbs and cessation of young lives. Let our young people live, please. Thanks Dave.
Francis [I trust it’s okay to address you as such; if no, please forgive me. I go by David]
I thank you deeply for taking the time to respond. And I offer my sincere apology for not being timelier in responding to your post. Illness and overload have taken too much space from me.
I too, like Einstein’s equation; he is one of my top role models. It started before I entered high school; he said “challenge authority because authority can be wrong.” That stuck in my mind and still does. I think it fits with your “empty barrels make the most noise.”
I agree with your thinking re: not supporting idea of war, losing young lives. Though we have a strong war muscle, we need to develop our diplomatic, peacemaking, and more humanitarian muscles. And constructive engagement is much more humanitarian than destructive engagement. We can do this differently; we can stop or at least minimize the loss of limbs and young lives.
Again, thank you very much! And I hope to hear from you more.
Onward!
I agree today’s leaders are not equipped to lead simply because they have completely different agendas. In the case of some, it is about proving something to themselves. While others have a thirst for power at any cost; rarely is it about servicing. It is unfortunate but that is one of the reasons for poor-decision making at the expense of others.
I agree – It is sad that we lack individuals with charisma who could possibly run the country. I believe that we have grown to be a self-centered society; a change that has occurred quite rapidly for reasons we have not even had time to properly examine. When there is no need for money, then there is a dire need for power. Unfortunately, there are few people in the world concerned for the well-being of others. I know that not everyone is religious, but I believe in a higher power and look to Him for guidance. Maybe if more of us did the same we will have a better world. If nothing at all, being religious appeals to one’s moral conscience which ultimately impacts thoughts and behavior.
Madelyn,
I hope you are well! I apologize for not being more judicious in responding to you. An illness and overload occupied more of me than I wanted. I thank you so very much for your response. I too believe we’ve become too self-centered; add to that greed, plus a hunger for power, leading to inhumane behavior, especially when it comes to culturally, ethnically, and religiously (etc.) different others. USA doesn’t deal with or embrace difference very well. I hear people say they love this country; but they hate half of its citizens. And though I am not religious, I believe in treating everyone in a socially just way; and since I am a social justice junkie, that impacts my thoughts and behavior.
I hope to hear from you in the future, Madelyn. And thank you so very much!
Please stay in touch.